From the Minnesota eMason
Written by Mark G. Robbins, PM, 33°, Grand Lodge Education Officer
Key Principles
So, let’s say you’re on vacation. It could be in another state, or it
could be in another country. You’re exploring the area around your hotel,
and you see a building with a square and compass on the outside, and the
sign by the door says they’re meeting that evening. You decide to stop
by to visit later. Or, you’re in the hotel restaurant having lunch, and
you see a man wearing a Masonic ring. You strike up a conversation, and
he invites you to visit his lodge while you’re there.
A perfect addition to your vacation, right? Maybe not. Do you dimly
remember something about not visiting a lodge of clandestine Masons, or
conversing Masonically with a clandestine Mason? What does that actually
mean? And how would you know?
The “conversing” part can be addressed quickly and easily. Your
Minnesota Masonic Manual (available as a pdf file on the
Grand Lodge web site if you don’t remember where your copy is) covers
just what you can discuss with a non-Mason. If you’re not sure if the man
you’re talking to is considered “clandestine,” the safest thing is to just
stick to what the manual says you can discuss.
But what of visiting? What defines a clandestine lodge, and how would
you know? The term “clandestine” gets used to cover several very different
statuses of purported Masonic bodies. To discuss this, we must first define
two terms: “regular,” and “recognized.” Regularity includes regularity
of practice, and legitimacy of origin. Regularity of practice refers to
adhering to what we generally think of as the ancient landmarks, while
legitimacy of origin means they can trace their authority to operate in
an unbroken line back to one or more of the Grand Lodges of England, Ireland,
or Scotland. For example, the three lodges that originally formed the
Grand Lodge of Minnesota were first chartered by the Grand Lodges of Wisconsin,
Illinois, and Ohio. If we look at Illinois, the lodges that created that
Grand Lodge were all chartered by Kentucky, which was formed by lodges
chartered by Virginia, which was formed by lodges chartered by all three
of the original Grand Lodges. Thus, a direct line of descent can be traced
from Minnesota back to England, Ireland, and Scotland.
The most egregious form is the completely “bogus” organization, one that was
formed out of thin air, with absolutely no Masonic authority, with the
intent to further the financial and self-aggrandizing motivations of the
men who started it. This is a problem that plagues many major cities in
the United States. The last time I checked, there were over 70 bogus
“Grand Lodges” in Illinois, almost all of them in the City of Chicago.
Many of them consist of only one lodge. They charge exorbitant fees for
membership and dues, most of which goes into the pockets of the men who
created the lodges. Many of their members are totally unaware that they
belong to an organization that is recognized by no legitimate Masonic
body. They’ve simply joined the lodge in their neighborhood that their
friends belong to, and fully believe that they are Masons. You’ll see
them join online Masonic discussion groups, and are shocked and skeptical
when told of their status.
Then you have some that have existed for a very long time, such as the ones
discussed in the last eMason. They are outgrowths of legitimate Masonry
and can claim legitimacy of origin, but have become irregular in their
practices, such as admitting atheists. A prime example of this
that was not discussed last month is the Grand Orient of France. This is
the oldest and largest Masonic body in France, and was recognized by
mainstream Masonry for a very long time, formed in 1728 as the Grand Loge
de France, becoming the Grand Orient in the early 1770’s. In 1876, they
dropped the requirement of belief in the Grand Architect. This resulted
in the United Grand Lodge of England (UGLE) suspending relations, and other
Grand Lodges followed suit. The French National Grand Lodge is recognized
by most jurisdictions, with the Grand Lodge of France by others.
Many Masons consider the UGLE to be the ultimate authority on recognition
and regularity. You’ll often see Masons asking how to know which Grand
Lodges are recognized, and they’ll be told “just look at the list on the
UGLE web site.” (
http://ugle.org.uk/about/foreign-grand-lodges) However,
this is not always good advice. While, as the oldest Grand Lodge in the
world they are certainly influential, each Grand Lodge is entirely autonomous,
and they make their own decisions about recognition and regularity. This
brings us to the concept of “regular but unrecognized.” For example, if
you were going to visit Italy, and looked at the UGLE list, you’d see that
they recognize the Regular Grand Lodge of Italy. However, Minnesota (and
the vast majority of other American Grand Lodges) recognizes the Grand
Orient of Italy. So, the body considered regular and recognized by UGLE
is unrecognized by our Grand Lodge, and is thus “clandestine” for the
purposes of visitation and discussion.
So, what should you do? If you know where you’re going and planning to
visit, the best thing is to check with the Grand Lodge office to clear
things beforehand. However, in the situation outlined in the opening
paragraph of this article, you may not have time to clear this. One
should always err on the side of caution, but recently I became aware of
a new, free “app” available for both Apple and Android devices, called
“Amity.” I have downloaded and activated it, and tested it on
some of the trickier situations, and found it to give accurate information.
I think it would be instructive to show you a few “screen shots” of what
the app does.
Here is the home screen (figure 1):
You can choose to check by country and state, (figures 2 & 3) to find out
what Grand Lodge is recognized by Minnesota, by clicking on the Amity button:
The “Lodge” button lets you type in a city by state or country, (figure 4)
and it will identify any recognized lodge or lodges in that city:
As a bonus, you can click on the MSA button, and read Masonic Service
Association “Short Talk Bulletins.”
This app is a definite boon to a traveling Mason. It would also be useful
for a check on the lodge and Grand Lodge of a visitor who shows up at
your lodge.
I hope this has been useful information for you.